top of page

E-Learning vs. Traditional Classroom Training: Which Is Right for Your Team?

Patrick Dunn

In today’s rapidly changing business world, investing in training and development for your team is crucial to staying competitive. However, with many options available, it can be challenging to determine the best method for your organization. E-learning and traditional classroom training are two of the most popular approaches, but which one is right for your team?


In this week's Branch Blog, we’ll compare the two methods, exploring the pros and cons, and offer insights into when to choose one over the other, supported by relevant statistics.


What is E-Learning?

E-learning refers to the use of digital tools and online platforms to deliver educational content. It offers flexible, self-paced learning through a variety of media, such as videos, quizzes, interactive modules, and discussion forums.

Advantages of E-Learning:

  1. Flexibility: Employees can learn at their own pace, which is ideal for teams with varying schedules or time zones. This is especially beneficial for remote teams.

  2. Cost-Effective: According to a study by the Brandon Hall Group, companies that use e-learning can save up to 60% on training costs. E-learning eliminates travel expenses and venue rentals, making it a more affordable option.

  3. Scalability: E-learning can be easily scaled to accommodate large teams, providing the same training to hundreds or even thousands of employees without the logistical challenges of in-person classes.

  4. Consistent Content Delivery: With e-learning, every employee receives the same training material, ensuring uniformity in how information is presented.


The hard numbers:

  • A report from the Learning House found that 70% of workers believe that e-learning allows them to learn at their own pace, resulting in better retention and performance.

  • According to Statista, 82% of employees prefer learning at their own convenience, demonstrating that e-learning offers flexibility that suits many modern work environments.


What is Traditional Classroom Training?

Traditional classroom training, also known as instructor-led training, is conducted in a physical setting with a live instructor. It typically involves face-to-face interaction, group discussions, and hands-on activities.

Advantages of Traditional Classroom Training:

  1. Interactive and Engaging: In-person training offers real-time interaction, which can help employees stay engaged and ask questions when they arise. This fosters a collaborative learning environment.

  2. Personalized Instruction: Trainers can assess individual needs more effectively and offer tailored support, which can be challenging in an online setting.

  3. Stronger Team Bonding: Classroom training offers an opportunity for employees to build relationships with colleagues, which can enhance team cohesion and morale.

  4. Hands-On Learning: Some topics, especially technical skills, are better taught in a practical, face-to-face environment, where employees can get direct, hands-on experience.


The hard numbers:

  • According to Training Industry, 57% of companies still prefer in-person training for technical skills and leadership development, suggesting that certain types of learning are better suited to traditional classrooms.

  • A survey from ATD showed that 44% of respondents believe in-person training has a more positive impact on engagement and retention compared to other methods.



Comparing E-Learning and Traditional Classroom Training

Both e-learning and traditional classroom training have their unique advantages. Let’s take a closer look at how they compare in key areas:

Criteria

E-Learning

Traditional Classroom

Cost

More affordable with fewer overhead costs.

Can be expensive due to venue and travel costs.

Flexibility

Employees can learn on their own time.

Set schedule that may not work for all employees.

Engagement

Can be less interactive depending on format.

Offers more direct engagement with instructors.

Effectiveness

Often effective for standardized content.

More effective for hands-on skills or complex concepts.

Scalability

Easily scalable for large teams.

Limited by physical space and trainer availability.

Retention

High retention for self-paced learning.

Better for in-depth, face-to-face discussions.

Which Is Right for Your Team?

The right choice depends on several factors, including the type of training required, the size and location of your team, and your overall objectives.

  • E-Learning Is Ideal For:

    • Large teams spread across different locations.

    • Ongoing or routine training (e.g., compliance, software updates).

    • Teams that need flexibility in terms of timing and pacing.

    • Cost-conscious organizations looking to reduce training expenses.

  • Traditional Classroom Training Is Ideal For:

    • Teams that need hands-on learning or technical skills training.

    • Situations where direct, real-time feedback is essential.

    • Teams looking to strengthen interpersonal skills and improve teamwork.

    • High-level leadership development where personal interaction is key.


Hybrid Approach: The Best of Both Worlds

For many organizations, a hybrid approach that combines both e-learning and traditional classroom training may be the most effective solution. According to a report by Brandon Hall Group, 71% of organizations are now combining online and in-person learning, recognizing the benefits of both methods. For instance, an e-learning module could be used for foundational knowledge, followed by an in-person workshop for practical application.


Final Thoughts

Ultimately, there is no one-size-fits-all solution when it comes to training methods. While online methods are convenient, in-person (or at least, live online) seems to have a positive impact on learning outcomes. Some of our data here is qualitative in nature, but there are certain kinds of learners who seem to appreciate the social interaction and accountability that comes with either a human instructor, or student peers.


At Branch, we think there's benefit in letting employees determine how they learn best; whether this is entirely online, hybrid online, or even in person. By leveraging the strengths of each approach and aligning them with your organization’s goals, you can create a more effective and engaging learning experience that empowers your team and drives success.

4 views0 comments

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


Branch Logo
  • LinkedIn

169 Enterprise Blvd, Markham, ON L6G 0E7

‪(437) 783-5121‬

© 2025 by Branch Academy

bottom of page